A clear definition first
Breast implant illness is the name patients and, increasingly, doctors use for a cluster of systemic symptoms attributed to implants: fatigue, joint and muscle pain, cognitive difficulty ('brain fog'), hair loss, rashes, dryness, sleep disturbance and anxiety, among others. It is not a formal diagnosis; there is no blood test, scan or biopsy that identifies it, and the same symptoms are common in people without implants. It is distinct from two conditions that are defined: rupture, which is seen on imaging, and BIA-ALCL, a rare lymphoma associated with textured implants that presents as late swelling or a fluid collection around the implant and is diagnosed on fluid analysis. Keeping the three apart is the first service a surgeon owes a worried patient.
What the research has shown — and hasn't
What is known: a substantial number of women report these symptoms; since 2021 the FDA has required implant labelling and a patient decision checklist to mention systemic symptoms; and several cohort studies report that a majority of women who undergo explant for these symptoms describe improvement afterwards, most clearly in the first year or two. What is not known: a mechanism, a way to predict who will improve, and whether the improvement reflects removal of the implant, the capsule, the operation itself, or the expectation of relief. Studies have not found a consistent immunological signature. An honest consultation says all of this in one breath, and does not replace it with either 'it's all in your head' or 'explant will cure you'.
Before deciding on surgery
Because the symptoms overlap with thyroid disease, anaemia, autoimmune conditions, perimenopause, sleep disorders and depression, the first step is a proper medical work-up with a physician — not to dismiss the implants, but to make sure nothing treatable is missed. Imaging of the implants rules out rupture and fluid. If, with that done, the patient prefers to live without implants, that preference is a sufficient indication for explant on its own; nobody has to prove that implants caused their symptoms to be entitled to have them removed.
What explant involves
The implant is removed through the old incision. The capsule is dealt with on its merits: a thin, healthy capsule can be left or partly removed; a thickened, calcified or contracted capsule is removed; a total capsulectomy is performed when the patient asks for it and it can be done safely, which usually means a capsule that is not fused to the ribs or very thin behind the muscle. En-bloc removal — capsule and implant together, unopened — is a specific technique for ruptured silicone with free gel and for suspected lymphoma; it is not a quality tier, and demanding it for a thin capsule adds bleeding and chest-wall risk for no demonstrated benefit. The removed capsule is sent for pathology when there is any clinical reason. Drains are common after capsulectomy.
What the breast looks like afterwards — and the options
This is the conversation that matters most and is had least. After years of an implant, the breast tissue is thinner and the skin larger than before; removal alone leaves a smaller, often deflated breast that improves over three to six months but rarely returns to its pre-implant shape. The options, set out in the removal guide: removal alone, which some patients prefer for simplicity; removal with a lift, which restores shape at the price of scars; and removal with fat transfer, which restores part of the volume with the patient's own tissue, sometimes in two sessions. Dr. Erdal shows each patient what her own tissue can be expected to give before anything is booked.
How an honest decision is made
The decision is made from three facts: the medical work-up, the imaging, and the patient's own preference about living with implants — not from a promise of symptom relief, which no one can make in good faith. Patients who choose explant are told what the surgery will and will not remove, what the breast will look like, and that follow-up includes their general health as well as their breasts. International patients can complete the work-up and imaging at home and send the results with photographs through the assessment; the recovery guide covers the stay and the flight home. A patient who wants her implants out will be helped to have them out, safely and with a plan for the shape that follows.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is breast implant illness real?
The symptoms are real and are reported by a meaningful number of women; whether implants cause them has not been proven, and there is no test that confirms or excludes the condition. Regulators now require implant labelling to mention systemic symptoms, and studies report that most women who have their implants removed for these symptoms describe improvement, at least in the first years. That is the honest state of the evidence.
Do I need an en-bloc capsulectomy for BII?
No evidence shows that en-bloc removal — capsule and implant taken out together as a sealed unit — is necessary for systemic symptoms. A total capsulectomy, removing all the capsule where that can be done safely, is a reasonable request; en-bloc is reserved for ruptured implants with free gel and for suspected BIA-ALCL, and it carries added risk when the capsule is thin or stuck to the ribs.
Will my symptoms go away after explant?
Many women report improvement, some report none, and no surgeon can promise either in advance. Explant should be chosen because the patient no longer wants implants and understands the breast she will have afterwards — not on the promise of a cure.